|Case of the Month|
Palmetto Princess, LLC v. Town of Edisto Beach
Palmetto Princess, LLC applied for a business license on February 23, 2003, to operate a “cruise to nowhere” which would originate and conclude within the waters and municipal boundaries of the Town of Edisto Beach. The plan was to have the vessel travel from the Town of Edisto Beach to a point beyond the three mile territorial waters of the State of South Carolina, at which time customers on the vessel would play games such as black jack, roulette, and craps, which are illegal on the South Carolina mainland, and then the vessel would return to the Town of Edisto Beach. Based upon Section 58-138 of the Code of Ordinances of the Town of Edisto Beach, which prohibits the possession of a gambling device on a vessel within the waters of the municipal boundaries of Edisto Beach, the application was denied.
Palmetto Princess then filed an action in the Court of Common Pleas in Colleton County seeking a judgment that the Town of Edisto’s ordinance exceeded the authority granted to it by the Legislature in S.C. Code Ann. § 5-7-30 and that it violated art. VIII, § 14 of the South Carolina Constitution. Judge Howard King found that the ordinance was not preempted by the Johnson Act, 15 U.S.C.A. §§ 1171 through 1175, and that the “cruise to nowhere” Palmetto Princess sought to operate was legal under the South Carolina Supreme Court’s decisions in Stardancer Casino, Inc. v. Stewart, 347 S.C. 377, 556 S.E.2d 357 (2001) and Diamonds v. Greenville County, 325 S.C. 154, 480 S.E.2d 718 (1997).
The Town of Edisto Beach now asks the South Carolina Supreme Court to review and reverse the decision of the lower court.
Briefs for this case are provided in Adobe Acrobat format. You must have the Adobe Reader software loaded on your computer to view these files. The Reader is available for free. Click on the Get Adobe Reader icon for further information, system requirements and to download the software.
Appellant's Final Brief (631 Kb)
|Respondent's Final Brief (425 Kb)|
|The oral arguments are presented in Windows Media Player format. You must have the Windows Media Player installed on your computer in order to view the streaming video. Click on the Windows Media Player icon to access information, system requirements and to download the player.|
(37 minutes playing time)
** Note: If you have problems viewing the video when using Internet Explorer, right click on the link and select "Open in New Window".